When to Throw Away the Marketing Rulebook

Chris Wilson

Chris Wilson

August 31, 2026

Sam & Ella’s Chicken Palace.

Say it out loud if you haven't caught on yet.

Years ago, I dined at Sam & Ella's in downtown Tahlequah, Oklahoma. Despite the name, they don’t serve chicken. They never did. What they do offer is pizza and subs—exceptional pizza, to be precise.

The name sticks because it’s a clever play on words, but also because it sounds a lot like salmonella.

For anyone managing marketing, this name is a red flag. You want your brand associated with quality and trust, not foodborne illness. A conventional branding agency would have likely dismissed that name before it ever reached the signage stage. Yet, it’s precisely why I remember it 18 years later.

The Trap of Best Practices

It's time to temporarily set aside the marketing rulebook, not abandon it entirely—just pause it for a week.

Problems arise when teams forget the original purpose of a rule. What begins as a principle becomes a best practice, then conventional wisdom, and eventually solidifies into an institutional process. Over time, no one recalls the problem the rule was meant to address.

That's when the rulebook ceases to protect you and starts to hinder you.

In established brands, this inertia is everywhere. You've invested heavily in marketing technologies, agencies, and standardized workflows. Questioning a fundamental assumption ("Is our core belief still valid?") feels like it could destabilize the entire infrastructure.

Question the Assumption, Not the Strategy

Discarding the rulebook doesn’t equate to reckless behavior, seeking attention through contrarianism, or abandoning strategy for random experiments. That’s not strategic courage; it’s gambling with company resources. The real task is to question the underlying assumption of a rule and assess whether it still holds true.

Consider personalization in technical outdoor e-commerce.

The playbook suggests that increased personalization boosts conversion rates, prompting marketing teams to develop intricate nurture sequences and segmentation models. But what if this complexity adds more friction than value?

Imagine a buyer evaluating breathability ratings, seam placement, and boot ankle support for cold-tailwater fly fishing waders. If you subject them to a hyper-segmented post-purchase sequence recommending fly-tying materials based on a quiz they completed three weeks ago, you miss the mark. They don’t want a personalized feather recommendation; they want clear instructions on wader care, patch kit usage, and layer compatibility.

You end up personalizing simply because your software allows it. The rulebook states that personalization is beneficial. The strategic question is whether it truly enhances the customer experience at that moment.

Best practices are starting points, not immutable laws.

Raising the Bar by Breaking Rules

They could have opted for a safe, forgettable name like Tahlequah Pizza Company or Mullen’s Subs. No one would have questioned it, laughed, or remembered it.

Instead, Sam & Ella's chose a name that creates intrigue. It makes you pause, smile, and step inside.

Breaking from convention involved a significant operational trade-off. A restaurant named Sam & Ella’s cannot afford any slip-ups in cleanliness. The joke only works if the dining experience starkly contradicts the name. They can’t risk a dirty table, an undercooked crust, or a single health inspection issue.

Making a bold marketing choice raises the bar for all subsequent operations. This isn’t a reason to avoid calculated risks; it’s why the strategy succeeds. As Seth Godin notes in his book "Tribes," “You eventually begin to realize that the safest thing you can do feels risky and the riskiest thing you can do is play it safe.” Safe choices render you invisible. The absence of risk doesn’t equate to safety—it’s a quick path to being forgotten.

Six Diagnostic Questions Before Breaking a Rule

Before you abandon an established marketing convention, consider these six diagnostic questions:

  1. Why was this rule created? Understand its historical context. Without knowing the operational or financial rationale behind it, breaking a rule isn’t innovation—it’s reckless.

  2. What assumption is essential? Identify what must be true for the best practice to make sense. Uncover the assumption buried beneath years of habit.

  3. What market condition has changed? Have customer behaviors, tech costs, channel economics, or competitor positioning shifted? If the environment has changed, the rule may be addressing an obsolete problem.

  4. What business outcome are you targeting? Break conventions only to improve margins, retention, acquisition, or positioning—not out of boredom.

  5. What is the potential downside if you’re mistaken? Develop a low-cost MVP. You need a controlled environment to measure failure without jeopardizing revenue.

  6. Is this a tactical rule or a core principle? Tactics evolve; principles remain constant. Customer trust, unit economics, clear value propositions, and financial discipline are non-negotiable principles, whereas campaign mechanics are tactics.

Don’t Confuse the Playbook with the Game

Japanese poet Matsuo Bashō once said: "Do not seek to follow in the footsteps of the wise. Seek what they sought."

If a competitor has a successful loyalty program, don’t blindly copy their tier structure. Understand the customer behavior they aimed to influence.

If a market leader dominates a specific channel, don’t automatically match their ad spend. Discover what customer friction they resolved.

The playbook shows how someone else succeeded in a particular situation. Strategy involves figuring out how to win the current game.

The rulebook is a tool, not an authority. The best leaders aren’t reckless rule-breakers; they’re observant pattern-recognizers who know when the environment has changed enough to warrant rewriting the playbook.

Chris Wilson, Marketing Strategist

Chris Wilson

As Vice President of Strategy at Publicis CRMOne and author of Fresh Peel, Chris examines why marketing strategies fail to produce expected growth. Over 20+ years, including 11 years at Oracle advising brands like Harley-Davidson, REI, and The North Face, he has helped executive teams diagnose post-purchase breakdowns. His work connects customer behavior, MarTech capabilities, and business economics to build systems that scale long-term customer value.

Advertisement

More to Explore

Why You Should Pursue a Career in Analytics

Why You Should Pursue a Career in Analytics

If you work within the business sector, it is likely that you have heard about the recent boom in job openings for analytics careers. If you are uncertain whether a career in analytics is right for you, here is a compilation of some of the top reasons why pursuing a...

read more