Deeper Inside the Music Industry

Now that Radiohead’s, much talked about album, In Rainbows, is being downloaded (paid for?? maybe) by fans all over the world, all eyes are looking in the bands’ direction to see what will happen now. I hope the band will eventually disclose some figures on how this panned out for them. How many times was album downloaded? What was the average price paid for the album?

But for now, if you want to get an idea of where the music industry is heading, you will have to look a little deeper into the industry just than whats been going on with Radiohead. No surprise here but it’s all about marketing.

 

Rick Rubin & WOM

Famous music industry great, Rick RubinLegend Rick Rubin has teamed up Columbia Records to be their new co-chairman. Rubin had this to say about his new position, in the New York Times, “In the past, I’ve tried to protect artists from the label, and now my job would also be to protect the label from itself. So many of the decisions at these companies are not about the music. They are shortsighted and desperate. For so long, the record industry had control. But now that monopoly has ended, they don’t know what to do. I thought it would be an interesting challenge.”

Rubin thinks that he can save Columbia by generating word-of-mouth using street teams and social media that hit up chat rooms, teen hot spots and hangouts. I think it’s going to take a little more than roughly contrived buzz to save this sinking ship.

 

Oasis & Jamiroquai

The Band, Oasis

Following the extreme amount of buzz created by Radiohead’s “pay what you want for it” internet release of In Rainbows, some big names in the industry are reevaluating their relationships with their music labels. Alan McGee, the manager of the Charlatans had this to say, “The record industry is obsessed by age and fashion. And so you get these amazing British bands like the Charlatans and the Happy Mondays that were massive 10 years ago and are still great, but are out of contract. How do you get them profile? You give away the record.”

There are also rumors that Oasis, and Jamiroquai are considering following in Radiohead’s release in similar fashion for their next albums.

 

The Format

The Formats Nate Ruess and Sam MeansThe Format is not a new name to The Fresh Peel. They are a band that I have discussed here a few times before (even did a phone interview with Nate Ruess, the bands front man), one because they are one of my favorite bands, and two because they tend to do things their own way.

One of the smartest thing I’ve seen the band do is give away their most recent album, Dog Problems, by making it free to download if you signed up for their newsletter. This happend right before they started a big tour and before releasing some new live material. I think a few factors that led to the idea to give the album away, one being that they realized the power that file sharing has played in their popularity and they decided to stoke the fire in that area and use word-of-mouth even more in that area. Also, by having fans sign up for the newsletter, they were given permission to keep fans updated on when live shows would be in their area, or when they were releasing new material. Thirdly, when I had my interview with Nate in April, he mentioned that he thought that the real money wasn’t in selling albums anymore and that the real cash these days is in merchandising and shows.

 

Brad Sucks

Brad Sucks, Steal This CD Brad Sucks is an interesting artist to include in this list. He is probably not a name that’s familiar to many of you, but I think his approach is worth noting.

As far as I know Brad, who calls himself “one man band with no fans,” has been giving away his music from day one, and ironically he doesn’t suck and has a few fans. Brad states that, “most of the ‘marketing’ Brad Sucks does is just fans spreading my songs. So while I might make a few more dollars up front, I’d be hindering that whole process and that doesn’t seem like a good trade for the long term.”

What’s even more unusual is that Brad lets people mashup, mix up, and screw up his tracks all they like. In fact, he encourages it by giving away the source files to his music willingly. In one of Brad’s latest self-promotions, from his blog, he offered up the source file to his newest song, Out of It, asking for readers to submit their attempts at backup vocals on the track.

 

Touring Giants

The Rolling Stones With the fall of the music label, some of the industries biggest names have found a gold mine in touring, which makes it even more appealing to leave the label out of the equation all together.

Here’s the complete list of the best-paid performers to tour the U.S. last year according to PollStar’s data (via Wire Blog):

  1. Rolling Stones $150.6m
  2. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill $132m
  3. Rascal Flatts $110.5m
  4. Madonna $96.8m
  5. Barbara Streisand $95.8m
  6. Kenny Chesney $90.1m
  7. Celine Dion $85.2m
  8. Bon Jovi $77.5m
  9. Nickelback $74.1m
  10. Dave Matthews Band $60.4m

Who cares about album sales, when The Rolling Stones, who haven’t released any new material, aside from greatest hits albums, is bringing home the most dough on the touring circuit.

 

‘Music Is Not a Loaf of Bread’

Jeff Tweedy, Wilco lead singerI couldn’t help but slip in some quotes from a Wired News interview with Wilco’s Jeff Tweedy, from 2004. It’s a few years old, but what Tweedy says is still relevant today.

WN: What if the efforts to stop unauthorized music file sharing are successful? How would that change culture?

Tweedy: If they succeed, it will damage the culture and industry they say they’re trying to save. What if there was a movement to shut down libraries because book publishers and authors were up in arms over the idea that people are reading books for free? It would send a message that books are only for the elite who can afford them.

Stop trying to treat music like it’s a tennis shoe, something to be branded. If the music industry wants to save money, they should take a look at some of their six-figure executive expense accounts. All those lawsuits can’t be cheap, either.

WN: How do you feel about efforts to control how music flows through the online world with digital rights management technologies?

Tweedy: A piece of art is not a loaf of bread. When someone steals a loaf of bread from the store, that’s it. The loaf of bread is gone. When someone downloads a piece of music, it’s just data until the listener puts that music back together with their own ears, their mind, their subjective experience. How they perceive your work changes your work. Treating your audience like thieves is absurd.

——-

This is pretty open-ended, but where do you think the music industry is headed?



New to The Fresh Peel?

Ronald Jenkees, The Real Deal

Ronald Jenkees Immitates no otherI knew it was time to pay attention to this self-proclaimed “nerd” from Kentucky, when I heard him make a connection from the classic rock band, Led Zeppelin, to hip-hop artists Jay-Z and Beyonce.

Ronald clearly understands the concept that “if you want to get noticed you can’t be a clone.” He doesn’t just bang around on a synthesizer imitating his favorite artists. He takes all of his musical influences, which I’ll note, appear to be all over the map, dumps them in a plastic bowl and pours his own special “Ronald Sauce” all over them.

To many, the persona that Ronald exhibits to the world via a camcorder from his bedroom, is in complete contradiction to what we normally think of in terms of successful musicians, celebrities, or anyone with influence for that matter. However, Ronald blows that idea out of the water with a strong following of over 6000 and rising subscribers on Youtube. He also recently released his long awaited CD, which is available on iTunes and at ronaldjenkees.com.

I believe his unique mix of nerd, Kentucky hick, and spare bedroom hip-hop gangsta may be awkward for some, but is largely what his success can be attributed to. Ronald’s not a clone of anyone. He’s 100% pure Ronald Jenkees. And lets not forget his unbelievable sound that I cannot begin to describe with words.

Check out one of his latest Youtube video to see him in action:

I don’t think we have heard the last of Ronald Jenkees. In fact, I think this is just the beginning. I know it is for me. I bought his CD ten minutes ago on iTunes.

——-

The first few times I watched Ronald I was amazed by his musical ability, but I just wasn’t quite sure if he was putting on an act with the coke bottle glasses and lame jokes. After watching all of his music videos on Youtube, I’ve come to the conclusion that if he’s not the real deal he has got his act down cold, and isn’t afraid of criticism.

So what do you think?

Is the real Ronald Jenkees the same guy that thousands are watching on Youtube?

Where do you think Ronald’s success stems from?

Mick Jagger, CEO

Rolling Stones Lips LogoThe regular Peelers know that I, on occasion, like to make references to bands and artists in the music industry, using them to create analogies and examples to marketing and branding.

In similar fashion, Stephen J. Dubner over at Freakonomics calls the Rolling Stones front man, Mick Jagger, the “Profit Maximizer” and compares him to a “supremely smart” CEO, for his direction of the Stones for the last 30 or so years.

I’ve said it before. I think there is a lot that can be learned from bands and artists in the music industry, and their approaches to business. There is an amount of freedom in the industry that allows them to explore different methods and keep pushing the limits.

Interview with The Format

Format


You are probably wondering how in the world are the happenings and opinions of a power pop rock band in any way relevant to the world of marketing? Honestly, I think there are a lot of things that can be learned in the corporate world from bands such as The Format. The band never seems to worry about conformity. In fact they were were dropped from Atlantic in 2005 because they wouldn’t conform to create the sound that the label wanted to hear. They are not afraid to bring something new to the table. That’s something that a lot of marketers and businesses a like need to learn. Like Marshall Goldsmith would say, “What Got You Here Won’t Get You There.” The truth is safe is risky.

———–

Phone Interview with The Format’s Nate Ruess (04/19/07)

 

Changing Dips

With Seth Godin’s new book, The Dip, just around the corner, Seth has been looking for successful people who at one time or another decided that it was time to stop settling for mediocrity and quit. As far as I know there aren’t any power pop rock bands on the list. Maybe The Format should be the first. In 2005, the band was dropped from Atlantic, which was their label at the time, and upon closer analysis you will find that the situation resembled more of a “fired before you can quit” scenario than the typical “band being booted by their label” scenario. Not every band can say that getting dropped from their label (twice) was the best thing that ever happened to them. In fact, in their bio The Format states that they threw parties both times it happened. Soon after getting dropped, The Format teamed up with Nettwerk to help with their management and distribution. By doing this, the band moved from what was a very large dip, run by the industry giants, where it took reaching the masses on a large scale to reach success at the top of “the dip”, and into a much smaller dip, where they answer to themselves and not the hierarchal structure above them. Royalties from music sales flow directly into their pockets instead of the slow trickle of money experienced when working with a large label.

Q: Tell us a little bit about the perks of running your own show and not having a big label breathing down your neck all the time?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Creating Format Worthy Content: Building Things Worth Noticing

In a world of cloning, look-a-likes, rip-offs and minor upgrades you have to create something worth noticing in order to be seen.

Q: You seem to be very unique and original with everything from your lyrics and music to your website and concepts for music videos. Everything seems to have The Format spin on it. What’s your method for creating Format worthy content?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Relationship Marketing: Interacting with Fans

The art of creating relationships is very important in the music industry. Seth Godin has been talking for years about Pearl Jam’s release of 72 live albums in two years, and they are all profitable. The reason they were successful is that Pearl Jam fans have a relationship with the band and are waiting and listening.

Q: How do you stay on top of interacting and creating relationships with your fans?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Creating Buzz

Without the backing of a major music label, The Format has to rely on their own resources to create buzz.

Q: What kinds of things do you do to encourage fans create more buzz about The Format?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Spin Tour Blog

Sometimes finding an established platform to stand on is the key.

Q: Tell me a little bit about your Tour Blog up at Spin. How did you guys get that gig?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

New Material

The masses don’t just want something new. They expect it!

Q: So when can we expect some new material from you guys? You recently mentioned to Mark Hoppus that you were in the process of recording a few new tracks.

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

New Song “Swans” & Working with a Full Band

It’s amazing how scarcity can make even the crudest products and information viral treasures. YouTube “Swans” footage from the School of Rock show in New Jersey last week.

Q: Tell me a little bit about the song titled “Swans,” that you revealed at the Jersey show.

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Things Change: Working with a Full Band

Since the beginning, The Format has been a two man band. Like their song, “On Your Porch” states, Nate Ruess and Sam Means have been writing songs together since they were kids.

Q: Do you think we will see any changes with having a full band?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Singing in Simlish

The practice of using video games as a promotional vehicle has been around since the beginning of the gaming industry itself.

Q: It’s a little known fact that “The Compromise” is featured on the Sims 2 Pets Expansion Pack, and like all the other songs in the game, it’s sung in the Sim’s language, Simlish. Did you actually record it this way, or was your voice mixed to create the Sims version?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:

 

Cross-Promotion or Happy Accident?

My first thought when I heard that a song from The Format was featured on the Sims 2 Pets expansion pack, was that there must have been some type promotional relationship in play. The connections are obvious, whether they were intentional or not. Both were released at relatively the same time. The Format’s album Dog Problems was released just 3 months before The Sims 2 Pets Expansion Pac. Both carry a pet related theme in their titles, and Nate Ruess has recently been quoted several times describing their music from the Dog Problems album as, “childlike.”

Q: Was there any connection between the song being featured on the “Pets” version of the game, with your latest album being titled, Dog Problems?

Listen to Nate’s Answer:


 

Format Your Marketing: Learn From the Band

The Format Band Tonight I’m going to Norman, to what will no doubt be an awesome live show. Guster and The Format have teamed up together on The Campus Consciousness Tour, to raise awareness of environmental issues.

The bands are aiming “to educate, inspire, and activate students, and above all leave a positive impact on each community and college/university that the tour reaches.” I’m excited to see both of the bands tonight, no matter what their reasons are for going on tour. Guster has been on my music radar for about 5 years now, and I am a huge fan of The Format, as many of you know from an earlier embarrassing post.

Within the last year however I’ve been impressed by The Format, not only because they released Dog Problems, a stellar follow up to Interventions + Lullabies, but because they have created a model for how a band can survive and market itself, and without the support of a major record label.

In 2005, The Format was dropped from Atlantic Records. They formed their own label for the release of Dog Problems, sarcastically named Vanity Label, and are using a company called Nettwerk for the distribution of their albums. This has given them the push of a major music label, in getting their albums into all of the major outlets, such as the Best Buy’s, Wal-Mart’s around the world, without getting pushed around themselves.

They also get a much larger percentage of royalties. This may seem like a dream scenario that every band should wish for, but one important part of the equation appears to be missing. Who is left to do the publicity and marketing for band? The answer is, The Format, and they do it very well. They may not have BA’s in marketing and public relations, but the band is resourceful. They exhibit some of the best examples of how relationship marketing and networking should be done. A true connection with fans goes along way.

If a band is loyal to its fans, the fans loyalty will extend twice as far. The same is true for businesses and customers. If a business is loyal to its customers, the customer’s loyalty will extend twice as far. Format, thanks for the lesson.

Singing Loudly & Off Key

Format SingleSeth Godin sent me into a flashback yesterday of a somewhat embarrassing experience I had at a concert last year. He wrote about listening to Live at Massey Hall: Neil Young and described how much more excited the crowd would get when the songs they knew were played, and in contrast how the crowd gave a, “tepid reaction,” to songs they did not know.

I’m a huge fan of the band, The Format, and after almost three years of rock hibernation (releasing a single here or there, with no live show to be seen) they were back on tour and were in the finally stages of getting their newest full album, Dog Problems, ready for release. Since they hadn’t played a live show in a while they were taking it slow getting back into the music scene, and I heard through their fan network that they would be doing a small show at the Farmers Market in OKC. I quickly marked the date on my calendar.

The night of the concert when The Format reached the stage I was stoked. For a while I didn’t know if the group was going to make a comeback, so to experience their music live gave me a refreshing jolt of confidence that one of my favorite bands would in fact be picking up right where they left off. I enjoyably sang loudly and proudly, knowing all the words to every song. After three or four Format greats, Nate, the lead singer of the band, said they would be playing a new song that would be on their next album. That’s when I found myself in a moment of awkwardness. As soon they started playing this song I unhesitatingly began singing loudly and off key just like I had to all the other songs. I quickly realized that no one else was singing, and looking at the rest of the crowd there were only one or two people who appeared like they might have even heard the song before.

I came to the quick realization that everyone else in the room wasn’t quite the Format junkie that I was. They hadn’t been sucking up every rumor, drop of news, music sample, and single release that had surfaced while the band was on a semi hiatus for almost three years. I had heard the acoustic version of this “new song” many times before that night. In fact, it was one of my 5-star favorites on my Ipod.

It’s interesting to look at how much more popular “new song” of the night has become. Now the song, “She Doesn’t Get It,” is being pushed as the latest single for their new album and a music video of the song has entered the MTV2 rotation. This is a good example of how being consistent with a good message, even when it is slow to be excepted, can make more of an impact over time.

Britney Spears Murdered Her Celebrity Brand

Britney BaldLast Friday, celebrity Britney Spears decided that she would kill her pop icon status, which took over a decade to create. Her brain waves were obviously malfunctioning when she shaved her head outside of a closed salon in Sherman Oaks, California. A celebrity’s visual image, or visual brand, should be one of their most valued assets. A superstar career is based on talent and ability but more than anything it is built on public image. And when I say image, I mean they must look the part. Take the TV show American Idol for example. Every once and a while you will see a contestant on the show that can belt out sweet lyrics like a pro, but because they don’t look the part they are turned away and even if they are advanced to the next round their success is short-lived. Britney’s carelessness with the scissors reminds me of similar situation that Keri Russel found herself in while staring on the hit TV series Felicity. On the show Keri was known for her long curly locks of hair, but in a personal need for change Russel decided to go for a much shorter look. It was obviously not as drastic of a change as Britney has made, but the decision left the viewers of a Felicity feeling as though they didn’t know her character any more. Some are calling Britney’s action a “publicity stunt”, but I say that unless she is planning on debuting a new brand of Britney, fronting a punk band in the near future, she has just committed celebrity suicide.