10 Most Overrated Brands

Lucas Conleys 10 Most Overrated Brands

Lucas Conley, contributing writer for Fast Company Magazine, author of Obsessive Branding Disorder and blogger, has put together a list for the Boston Globe, of he what says are the 10 Most Overrated Brands.

Conley argues that,

companies are desperate to capture the interest of fickle consumers. More are increasingly relying on image makeovers to boost their businesses; often more than the harder work of actually improving their products.

With that said, his list includes many of marketers long time favorite brands. Conley says he

offers us 10 brands that have stayed in the fridge well past their expiration dates.

I’ve included Lucas’ full list below:

  1. Southwest Airlines
  2. The Gap
  3. The Los Angeles Lakers
  4. Oprah
  5. MTV
  6. Dunkin’ Donuts
  7. Victoria’s Secret
  8. Apple
  9. Trump
  10. The Everybrand

  —-

What do you think?

Have some of marketing’s “role model brands” lost their luster?

Post to Twitter

Simple Idea: Grown vs. Built

Simple Idea, Branding Grown BuiltExceptional brands are grown, not built.

 

 

Post to Twitter

Ronald Jenkees and the Grey of Authenticity

Ronald Jenkees Grey of Authenticity

It’s been almost a year since I first wrote about Ronald Jenkees and his “unique mix of nerd, Kentucky hick, and spare bedroom hip-hop gangsta.” At the time, I was not only mesmerized by Ronald’s genius keyboard skills, but the unique YouTube personality that is “Ronald Jenkees.”

But over the past 4 months or an undercurrent of controversy surrounding Jenkees has started to creep to the surface. It seems there are quite a few people who have a problem with Jenkees’ persona on YouTube. In fact, some of them think that Ronald Jenkees is a blatantly fake character, that was created with the sole intention of gaming the YouTube crowd.

This has led to lively discussions in forums, Fresh Peel comments, and in the YouTube comments section.

Out of all comments I’ve read in regards to Jenkees, very few criticize his music. The point of confrontation seems to always stem from differing opinions of just how authentic Ronald Jenkees is.

I’ve found there to be three very different opinions on Ronald’s authenticity:

  1. Ronald Jenkees is an outright fake.
  2. Ronald Jenkees is a talented musician that has created stage personality.
  3. Ronald Jenkees is totally authentic. All the hats, funny voice, and stupid sayings are 100% Jenkees.

This again begs the question, what is the true definition of authenticity?

Is there no place in the conversation age for characters, fictional stories and stage names? Must everything be presented with a disclaimer in order to truly be authentic?

If that’s the case, transparency could make things pretty boring.

What do you think?

Post to Twitter

The Crazy Process


(They disabled embeds on this video. You can view it here.)

The only thing left out of this story is a board of about 30 people, who interrupt the process at random times and vote about the small details of the project.

Via: Brand New & John Winsor

Post to Twitter

Human Talk: Airlines

Flight Delayed

As we near the end of summer here in the States, and many are in the middle of what is a heavy traveling season. Whether its for a vacation with the family, a conference or workshop, or just business as usual. Many of you have caught a plane or two or more in over the past few months, and probably have more travel plans in the future.

For most people this is something that they dread. We’re all too familiar with the frustrations of flying: expensive tickets, delays, long lines, grouchy employees, lost luggage, wall-to-wall people in the terminals, more delays.

Sadly, the airline industry has become a necessary evil for most of us.

Back in March, Al St. Germain, Global Director for Airline Practice at Landor Associates, wrote an article titled Said and done: Stories from on board the airplane. He highlighted many of the overwhelming problems that the industry is facing, as well indicating how important an asset customer service is in the mix.

I clipped out his tips on developing great customer service because of how hand and hand customer service is to the concept of Human Talk. Who better to give a company a human voice than the people on the frontlines interacting with customers on a daily basis?

Germain writes:

What makes great customer service?

Consistency

The bigger you get, the harder it is to achieve, but nothing makes a customer happier than knowing what to expect every time they step on board. Every time a customer buys a ticket, it’s a promise from your brand. No one likes a broken promise.

Empathy

The airline industry is a classic example of employees rarely experiencing what its customers do (pass-riding does not count!). It takes significant effort to ensure that folks truly understand what a customer may be going through. And in the often high-stress world of travel, a little empathy goes a long way.

Support

Wonderful customer experiences are the result of a lot of hard work behind the scenes. As a frontline employee, it’s much easier to create better interactions when your product works, the process is designed to make sense, and most of all, when your efforts are recognized by your leadership.

Style

While not everyone can (or should) be hip and cool, everyone needs to stand for something. What is the uniquely memorable aspect of your experience? Being “friendly” is great, but I guarantee every other airline has “friendly” in its service standards. What will your customers talk about when they get to their destination?

As you will notice, one thing that didn’t make it to Germain’s list is the need to explain break down the airlines cost structure to the passengers. I wonder what airlines are thinking when they decide to clutter procedures with extra fees for passengers to agree to, and the rabid slash and burn of any extra service that used to be included in the ticket price.

We all know that the price of gas is rising. Therefore, anyone with half a brain would realize that airline ticket prices will also rise. No reason to inconvenience and annoy passengers even more with added steps and decisions to make. All it does is add stress to what is already a stressful situation.

One airliner that seems to get it is Virgin Airlines. They realize that a little humorful Human Talk can go a long way.

Virgin Airlines Bag Limit 

Photo Credit: Flickr 

 Virgin Baggage Carousel Rides 

Photo Credit: Flickr

Virgin Airlines Jet Engine

Photo Credit: Flickr 

——

This post is part of the Human Talk series. 

If you would like to contribute your good or bad Human Talk examples, Email me. I’ll accept photos, stories, videos, audio, etc. and give credit where credit is due.

Post to Twitter

Post2Post Virtual Book Tour: Featuring Jack’s Notebook

Post2Post Tour Featuring Greg Fraley Author of Jacks Notebook

The bus has just pulled in!

The Fresh Peel is pleased to welcome Gregg Fraley, author of Jack’s Notebook, which is the featured book for July’s stop on the Post2Post Virtual Book Tour.

Gregg works as an innovation consultant to Fortune 500 companies and does keynote speeches and workshops on creative thinking, innovation, problem solving, and new product development. You can catch his podcast with Doug Stevenson where they team up as The Innovise Guys where they blend creativity and improvisation to create innovation.

Fraley is a board member of the Creative Foundation (CEF), and he teaches creative problem solving at CEF’s annual Creative Problem Solving Institute (CPSI). He is also a professional member of the National Speakers Association (NSA).

Jack’s Notebook is a a business novel that explores the process of CPS through the fictional tale of Jack Huber. As you will read later, Gregg defines CPS as, “a problem solving methodology and it can be used to help develop solutions for any complex challenge, problem, situation, or opportunity.”

This Post2Post stop features two sections. Enjoy!

  1. Creative Problem Solving (CPS)
  2. CPS in Marketing & Branding

 

——

Be sure to check out the February Fresh Peel Post2Post stop with Ramon Vullings of Creativity Today.

 

Post to Twitter

Interview with Author Gregg Fraley: CPS in Marketing & Branding

Creative Problem Solving in Marketing & Branding

Gregg Fraley is the author of Jack’s Notebook.

Greg works an an innovation consultant to Fortune 500 companies and does keynote speeches and workshops on creative thinking, innovation, problem solving, and new product development 

I couldn’t pass up the opportunity pick Greg’s brain and squeeze out some of his juicy thoughts on marketing, branding and how he thinks creative problem solving applies to the mix.

Q: When it comes to building brands, what mistakes do you commonly see?

Gregg: With regard to new brands, I’d say a lack of differentiation, a lack of consistency, and a lack of authenticity. I mean the best brands are truly unique and they stay true to themselves. Examples that come to mind are Apple, but also brands like Quaker Oats, or Budweiser. They do what they do well and they stay within the confines of what is believable and real to consumers. With big established brands the dangerous tendency is to water down the brand by extending it into areas where it really doesn’t belong. Line extensions are easy, and so they extend and extend until the brand caves in on itself.

 

Q: What is your view of the state of organizational marketing and branding? Where should CPS fit into these structures?

Gregg: There’s a $64,000 question! Let me give it a go.

Organizational marketing is going through a profound shift right now, a shift towards more formal process. The state of Marketing, while highly sophisticated in many ways, is still managed by informal systems within most organizations. Typically, they have no overall model for how to answer the needs of the consumer and fulfill the companies mission across the breadth of the enterprise. Each product, each brand, tends to be handled separately from the others. What this screams for is a formal marketing process that is flexible enough to adapt to the needs of various brands but tight enough to bind them to the organizational mission. CPS, being a generic problem-solving model, has the scope and flexibility to manage this.

 

Q: Why is understanding your motivation so important?

Gregg: It’s human nature to work harder, smarter, and more creatively on challenges that we care about. If we understand why something is important to us it’s more likely we’ll be creative about it. You can’t fool that thing some people call the soul, it knows what you really want even if you pretend otherwise.

 

Q: How does this concept fit into marketing? Social Media?

Gregg: Well, motivation is a two way street. As marketers we need to understand why we’re putting out something we need to understand our mission and our message. As consumers we need to feel that the mission and message of the companies we buy from is authentic and not simply a cynical way to extract money from our pockets. Marketers need to understand consumer motivations at a very basic, very fundamental, level. Knowing the consumer in that way enables a marketer to create products, services, and messages that speak to their listening.

Social media tends to magnify who we are.  If we’re authentic, that comes across, and it can be quite powerful. If we’re not, that comes across as well, and probably worse than it should. So, keeping the fact in mind that social media adds or subtracts 10 pounds to our authenticity factor, we should make double sure we know what we want to say, and why we want to say it. As marketers using social media we have to be very careful we’re providing value to the community and not simply selling products. After all, social media isn’t about we and them, it’s about us.

 

Q: With the introduction of social media and crowdsourcing, do you think there is an opportunity for a company to lead and monitor a CPS session with customers online?

Gregg: Yes, there is such an opportunity.  Actually, it’s already happened in a slightly different format than you suggest. Cisco just sponsored an online contest, using Brightidea.com’s system, to find a new business venture to fund. It wasn’t exactly CPS but it most certainly was high level ideation, which is a part of CPS.

Many companies are already using CPS internally via their intranets, and some are using it to reach out to partners. I’ve facilitated online CPS sessions that have involved a mix of a companies internal branding/marketing people and an international network of trained brains. They tend to be pretty successful these sessions because they allow people to work when they can, it allows for adequate incubation, and there’s lot of thinking diversity. It’s certainly a lot less expensive than flying a lot of people into some central site.

It doesn’t have to be complex. Starbucks has an online idea box if you will, which isn’t full cycle CPS, it’s a subset, the ideation step. It’s called MyStarbucksIdea.com and I think it’s a good idea for them. Subsets of the CPS process can be totally appropriate, I mean, how many consumers would even want to be involved with the detailed planning that goes into a product launch?

Virtual CPS sessions, with consumer involvement for the appropriate steps, makes total sense. It’s inexpensive, easy to implement, and potentially very high value.

 

Q: What would you say to an organization that is clearly stuck in the old model of marketing, which is rapidly losing its effectiveness? Is CPS the answer to overcoming their apparent risk aversion?

Gregg: What would I say? Wake up!

It’s hard to understand sometimes why organizations can’t see the handwriting on the wall. Maybe the answer is tough love. Like in the Dickens story, we have to put the ghost of Christmas future in front of them. It can be grim, or, it can be rosy. But for Tiny Tim to live, they have to wake up and change now!

CPS could be a big part of the answer. CPS is a great process for facing a fear, or a complex situation, and making some sense out of what you might do. If an organization is motivated to change than CPS can be a tremendous tool for helping them do it. Risk aversion build up in organizations as they get bigger. The bureaucracy is built to manage things as they are, and so, change threatens the well-oiled system. It puts people in fear mode. Fear has people thinking like lizards when faced with a threat lizards run, eat, (or mate!) with what’s in front of them. You can’t think like a lizard and change how your organization goes to market; you need imaginative solutions. Organizations should strive for deliberate, continuous, and holistic innovation, and CPS is a good process to enable that. And of course, Jack’s Notebook is a great way to learn CPS!

 

Thanks Gregg!

Have any questions about CPS in Social Media, Branding and Marketing?

Gregg has agreed to take questions in the comments section, so fire away!

More with Gregg Fraley:

Creative Problem Solving (CPS)

 

Post to Twitter

Interview with Author Gregg Fraley: Creative Problem Solving (CPS)

Creative Problem Solving 

Gregg Fraley is the author of Jack’s Notebook.

Greg works as an innovation consultant to Fortune 500 companies and does keynote speeches and workshops on creative thinking, innovation, problem solving, and new product development.

Q: What is CPS and where can we use it?

Gregg: CPS is a problem solving methodology and it can be used to help develop solutions for any complex challenge, problem, situation, or opportunity. If you’re hunting for your car keys you probably don’t want CPS, it’s too much! If you’re trying to sort out how your brand fits in the marketplace and what do next year, CPS is an appropriate system.

Creative Problem Solving Chart(CPS)

 

Q: You shared with me a story about the origins of CPS. Would you mind sharing that story with my readers?

Gregg: Sure, it’s an interesting story. CPS has been around for over 50 years. CPS was originally conceived by ad maven Alex Osborn, a founder of BBDO. Alex was confronted with the daunting challenge of transforming BBDO. BBDO’s initial stage of growth was all print media. The dominant media of the day was newspapers. But as we know, things changed, and print was being eclipsed by the new media juggernaut, radio. BBDO almost imploded when the key sales person at the agency left and took half the customers with him. Faced with this crisis, Alex needed to give his account executives tools to help their customers adapt to the new media. They needed to think up ideas for their customers and with their customers, but they lacked the confidence to do so. Alex had developed thinking tools for his own use over the years. So, he put down his own methods for ideation on paper. He then trained his team in these thinking tools — what he called brainstorming. Yes, he actually coined that term! Well, it worked, his people brought in new customers by helping them with ideas. BBDO became known as a great ideas agency and prospered with the new media. Alex then took his thoughts about creative thinking and put them into the seminal book Applied Imagination and the basics of CPS was born

 

Q: What is the most common mistake you see by those engaged in the creative problem solving process?

Gregg: Well, the most common mistake is not using a process at all.  When faced with complexity the brain tends to spin or churn from one thought to another related to the problem. We tend not to write things down and so we muddle about in confusion. The value of a structured process like CPS is it helps us sort it out. Sort out what we want, what the facts and feelings are, what the challenge really is, and what are our options for moving forward. It helps us push beyond the obvious and find breakthrough solutions.

If you are already using the CPS process the answer would be not allowing enough time. A common mistake in problem solving is rushing to a solution. Taking time allows the mind time to incubate the question at hand. Time tends to lend insight and insight leads to more creative solutions.

 

Q: What’s the significance of lists?

Gregg: List making, particularly when it is done without judgment, is the easiest way to get into imaginative mode. The mind seems to like the incremental aspect of list making, and, it tends to give us what we want, which is more options. List making is divergence and in general we need more divergence in our thinking. Critique and analysis are overemphasized in our education and training, and divergence is left behind. List making is a great way to re-balance things.

 

Q: Could you give us some tips on making great lists?

Gregg: First of all, write them down (it’s not called Jack’s Notebook for nothing!). Mental lists tend to get lost in the shuffle of the 65,000 thoughts we have a day. Next, know what the questions is, what you are seeking options for, be clear about that. Most of all, defer judgment and let any option that pops into your head get onto the list, don’t edit. Sometimes silly, impractical, or wild ideas are the steps the mind needs to take in order to get to a Perfect idea. Finally, when blocked put your list aside and take a short vacation from the challenge, give it some time, then come back to it. New options will emerge.

 

Q: I noticed that the characters in your story seemed to always engage in CPS when they were in small groups of no more than 4 people. Was this just a happenstance, or is there a maximum number for people working together through CPS?

Gregg: Happenstance! There is no minimum or maximum, CPS can be done alone, or, with large groups. I did a session a few months ago for a cosmetics company that included over 70 people and three languages. The groups in Jack’s Notebook just happened to be about that size of four or less because it’s what the story called for. I’ve found that groups of 15 or less are optimal for corporate ideation. Larger than that it becomes a logistics challenge, smaller, and you don’t have a lot of thinking diversity. It can still be done you work with what you have.

 

Q: You seemed to put a lot of emphasis on the correct phrasing of questions. Why?

Gregg: Well, that’s part of the structure behind creative problem solving. Words are what we have to work with in problem solving. Words point the brain in different directions depending on how a question is phrased. For instance when you have a challenge you could say, How did this project become so expensive? That kind of question leads one to think about the past, and it invites critique. Saying it as a solvable problem takes us down a different path, so In what ways might I reduce the costs of the project? has us thinking about ideas, about options, that bring the cost down. Phrases like In what ways might I, or How might I are empowering and provide a subtle bit of hope. They challenge the brain to come up with answers that are useful, and, the brain tends to respond well to that.

 

Q: Many companies are quick to start planning, but are very slow to act. Often times plans never make it any farther than the board room or company retreat. Why?

Gregg: There are a lot of reasons, but that most basic one is the person or team empowered to execute the plan isn’t motivated to change. In my opinion, and it’s unfortunate, many organizations aren’t motivated to make a change unless there is an emergency that demands it. Board rooms and retreat situations often get people thinking, and that’s good, but they tend to use the critical/analytical side of the brain too much and so the plans they generate are often all head and no heart. If you don’t have the heart to do something it simply won’t happen.

 

Q: What should they do instead?

Gregg: It should be less of a one meeting thing and more of an all the time way of being. Innovation is holistic it’s not doing an activity, it’s being, living, breathing, eating, and waking-up-in-the morning in innovative mode. An organization needs a deliberate and formal holistic system, like CPS, to enable consistent innovation. Adopting a particular tool, technique, or hiring a dynamic and charismatic leader isn’t going to get it for you. What will get it for you is a holistic approach that blends many complex elements into a gestalt that is greater than the sum of its parts.

 

Q: Your bio states that you, work as an innovation consultant to Fortune 500 companies. What types of situations and problems do you typically help these companies solve?

Gregg: All kinds! Most typically it’s around new product development. My bread and butter work is facilitating intensive new product ideation sessions. I’ve also worked on and facilitated projects for internal process improvement. More recently I’m getting involved in assessing an organizations innovation culture and making recommendations on how they might improve.

Thanks Gregg!

Have any questions about Creative Problem Solving? Want to know how CPS can help you find the perfect mate?

Gregg has agreed to take questions in the comments section, so fire away!

More with Gregg Fraley:

CPS in Marketing & Branding

 

Post to Twitter

Audi Manufacturing with Orchestra

Last month, I shared a VW’s sounds of doors slamming music mix commercial. Now Bullet has done a series of work for Audi providing their own take on the music of car sounds, this time focusing on the orchestrated production of the vehicles.

The music blends an odd mix of elegance, quality, and edgy trendiness. It’s a lot like Radiohead or NIN in tuxedos.

—–

Sounds like Audi to me. What do you think?

Via: brandflakesforbreakfast

Post to Twitter

It Only Takes One

Red River New Mexico Street Valley

For the long holiday weekend, I traveled to Red River, New Mexico with my wife for a little stream fishing and relaxation in the cool of the mountains. This was only my second time to visit the New Mexico mountains at this time of year, but I have quickly come to love the relaxing calm that travels through the valleys.

It’s refreshing. That is, until you interact with the locals, the one owners of the restaurants, gift shops, cabins, and bait shops.

The truth is that Red River has a problem. The problem is the local people have been running their businesses the same way, giving customers service that fits into their schedules instead of meeting customer needs and expectations, for decades. And the fact that people continue to visit has sent them into a state of complacency and mild apathy.

The attitude of the Red River locals is “I’ll do things the way I want, when I want.”

Restaurants didn’t have posted hours, they would shut down when they felt it was time to quit. We literally walked 3 restaurants at 8:30pm right after they had seated another group and were told that “they were closed.”

The majority of the gift shops didn’t allow customers to use their bathrooms because, “it’s their policy.” Some outright lied and said that they don’t have a bathroom.

I don’t say all this to rant and rave about how I hate Red River, NM. Just the opposite. I love Red River and I don’t want to see it wither away because of no one in the town has the guts to challenge the status quo.

Fact is, all it would take to give the local culture of Red River a complete 180 is one. It would take just one business in Red River, meeting and then exceeding customer expectations. It would take one shop that welcomes customers in, even if it is just to use the bathroom. If just one would insist on changing the rules it would force the whole town to change or watch their businesses die a painful death

Be brave enough to stand up and be the one. If you don’t someone else will, and then it might be too late.

(Image via: Zeality

Post to Twitter

July 4th: The Facts

July 4th American Flag Independence Day

Here are some interesting facts about the ole’ US of A, and Independence Day. Not surprisingly, China has a hand in producing for the festivities.

  • In July 1776, there was an estimated 2.5 million people living in the newly independent nation. (Historical Statistics of the U.S.)
  • On this July Fourth, there is an estimated population of 304 million living in the United States. (Population Clock)
  • In 2007, $4.7 million in American flags were imported into the United States. The majority, $4.3 million, were made in China. (Foreign Trade Statistics)
  • Also in 2007, $1.2 million in U.S. flags were exported from the United States to Mexico. (Foreign Trade Statistics)
  • China exported $217 million in fireworks to the United States in 2007. (Foreign Trade Statistics)

Have a safe and happy holiday!

 

Post to Twitter

Post2Post Tour Strikes Again: July 14th-18th

Post2Post Returns July 2008

After a successful Post2Post round back in February, with Creativity Today, the Tour is heading this way again!

Jacks Notebook Gregg FraleyContinuing with the subject of creative problem solving, The Fresh Peel will be hosting Gregg Fraley, author of Jack’s Notebook.

Something that I’ve found very interesting with Jack’s Notebook, is that wasn’t written in the typical business book format. The principles are laid out and applied in the style of an entertaining novel, which is probably why the subtitle reads, “a business novel about creative problem solving.” This makes the concepts enjoyable, easy to digest and remember.

Gregg writes in the introduction,

“If you are struggling to move ahead in your career, if you’re an executive with a thorny corporate challenge, someone trying to solve a messy community issue, a family trying to sort through an emotional conflict, or an entrepreneur looking for ways to make the most of limited resources-this book is for you. If you have a ‘mess’ on your hands, you have found a useful tool.”

Below is the full Post2Post schedule:

Site Date
Education Innovation
Rob Jacobs
Mon, July 14
The Naked Idea
John Lepp
Tue, July 15
The Marketing Fresh Peel
Chris Wilson
Wed, July 16
InnoBlog
Various Authors
Thur, July 17
The Brand Chef
Andrew Clark
Fri, July 18

 

For more information on the Post2Post Tour, visit Idea Sandbox.

 

Post to Twitter

Simple Idea: Formulas

Simple Idea: FormulaTo change the game you always have to break the formula.

Post to Twitter